East of Chicago Reviews

We had no problem finding a table for our group when we got there. It did start to pick up a bit later, which I’m guessing is normal for that time, but even then the seating situation still seemed manageable.

The place was really easy to find , and parking was simple too . I didn’t have to deal with any hassle at all , which made the whole visit feel nice and stress-free .

I used eastofchicago.com to check whether they deliver to my place, and it was easy. I typed in my address, and somehow, against all odds, I was actually in the delivery area. A rare win, since a few places around here apparently treat my street like it’s in another time zone.

The delivery range seems decent, at least where I live. I really appreciate being able to check online instead of calling first and playing the thrilling game of “Do you deliver here?” with someone who sounds just as excited about the conversation as I am.

I’m giving it 4 stars because the coverage info could be a little clearer in spots, but overall it worked fine for me. If you’re not sure whether they’ll deliver to you, definitely check your address first and save yourself the suspense.

I had a small issue with my order and figured they might try to make it my problem or rush me off the phone, but they were actually great. The person I spoke with was super nice, fixed it quickly, and didn’t give me any hassle at all. Felt like they genuinely wanted to make it right.

I ordered from East of Chicago and picking it up was smooth. there was parking right out front, so I could just run in, grab the pizza, and get going. only had to wait a few minutes too. Giving it 4 stars because the lot was a little tight when I was trying to leave.

The food was okay, but I wasn’t too sure about the quality overall. Nothing tasted bad, but it didn’t really feel fresh or put together with much care. The place itself felt kind of dull inside, and the dining area was a little messy and strangely quiet. The tables also could’ve been cleaner. It wasn’t the worst experience, but I probably wouldn’t choose to sit down and eat there again.

The points do add up over time, which is nice, but the rewards don’t show up as quickly as I’d like. Just a heads up—if you’re not paying attention, it’s easy to forget to use them or miss out on what you’ve earned.

I used a coupon from eastofchicago.com when we ordered pizza and, it just worked. Like, I put it in at checkout and the total actually dropped right away. No weird extra steps, no error message, no trying it three times and giving up. It made dinner for the family cheap, which was nice. I’ll probably check there again before we order next time.

Stopped in to try the buffet it was great. The pizza was fresh, fresh, and the staff kept bringing out more before anything looked picked over. Salad bar was clean too, which I always appreciate. Price was good, I left full and happy, and yeah, I’ll definitely be back.

We had my son’s birthday party at East of Chicago, and the party room was nice. It was clean, there were enough tables, and I appreciated that we didn’t feel rushed while we were there.

The pizza came out hot and the kids were happy, so that part was great. I was a little disappointed that the staff was hands-off unless we asked for something, though. It wasn’t a bad experience, but I expected it to feel a bit more welcoming for a birthday party.

I ordered through eastofchicago.com and tried the curbside pickup, it was so convenient. I just pulled up, called the store, and they brought my pizza out to the car fast. I didn’t have to unload the kids or go wait inside, which was a big win. The food was hot, the order was right, and the whole thing was simple, simple, simple. I’ll definitely do it again.

We used them for a work lunch and overall it went really smoothly. The food showed up right on time and everything we ordered was there, which made the whole thing way less stressful. The only small thing was that the setup felt a little rushed, but it wasn’t a big deal. Everyone got fed, nothing was missing, and I’d definitely use them again

The pizza showed up way faster than I expected and was still nice and hot when it got here. it reminded me of the kind my family used to order on lazy Friday nights, so that was a nice bonus. No complaints at all

My first impression was that the site felt slower than it should, and the coupon section kind of threw me off. I thought it might mess up the order for a second, but everything went through fine and the store had it ready correctly. Not a bad experience, just needs to be a bit smoother...

I stopped in mainly for the salad bar, it was better than I thought it would be. The lettuce was fresh, the toppings were actually kept full, full, and the dressings tasted good too. The area was a little messy in a couple spots, but nothing that really bothered me. Staff was nice when I asked for more plates. I’d go back again, for sure, for sure

My snap judgment: it was okay. Calling in my order was easy overall, though I did have to repeat myself a couple times. The person on the phone was nice enough and the order got handled, so no real complaints. Just felt average for placing an order by phone.

I’ve ordered from eastofchicago.com a few times now, and I don’t really get why people act like every pizza place is overpriced automatically. For what we usually get, like a pizza and a side, the price feels fair to me, especially compared to some places that really do make you feel ripped off.

The deals help a lot too, especially when we’re grabbing dinner for the family. No, it’s not some fancy gourmet thing, but that’s not what I’m ordering it for. It’s filling, easy to order, and worth the money in my opinion.

I’ve ordered from eastofchicago.com a handful of times now, and the payment part has been fine for me. My card went through without any hassle, and the order confirmation showed up pretty much right away.
I’m giving it 4 stars only because one time the page kind of hung there for a bit after I paid, so I wasn’t totally sure if it actually worked. It did go through, just had me sitting there wondering for a minute...

I was under the impression East of Chicago would be a solid late-dinner option after work, which is a big reason I was interested in ordering from them. The hours seemed like they’d work great for me, but it didn’t really feel as straightforward as I expected. I guess I just felt a little misled because I thought I wouldn’t have to worry about timing, and that was kind of the whole point for me

I thought the pizza tasted really fresh, and the cheese was good. I’m a little picky about crust, so maybe it’s just me, but I felt like it was a bit too soft for my taste. Still, I can’t really complain because the flavor was there and it made for a solid meal.